Good news from the House of Lords

Last month, Asociat joined a coalition of over 200 businesses, who petitioned the House of Lords to reject the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill – a bill which we collectively believed to be bad for business and bad for democracy.


On Monday 17th Jan 2022 there was good news (for now at least) from the House of Lords – the bill was significantly defeated; a triumph for the business campaigners and the many hundreds of thousands who have protested in the streets under the so called Kill the Bill banner. The signatories to an open letter to the Lords included Innocent Drinks, The Body Shop, Patagonia and Ben & Jerry’s – a company who impressively employ a Global Head of Activism. Asociat were proud to be among them.


A TV dragon also breathed fire into the campaign. Deborah Meaden was featured in the Evening Standard – her quote echoed the feelings of the coalition; “Giving voice to those who challenge and disrupt the status quo is an essential part of business. It creates a culture of innovation and leads to better ways of doing things. The same applies in society.”


Here! Here!

As we said in an earlier post about our opposition to the bill – in the UK there is a proud tradition of protest. If not for the right to protest the right for women to vote just wouldn’t exist today. In fact, Labour’s Lord Hain used that very argument in his own dismissal of the bill saying that it would have “throttled” protests by the suffragettes (had its clauses existed as law at the time).

So, what was wrong with the Bill then?

Among other things it proposed…

  • Imprisonment for attending a protest deemed ‘noisy’ or ‘disruptive’ . Even if you weren’t the people being either of those things
  • Imprisonment for merely being found in possession of carrying protest equipment such as a banner or a placard
  • ‘Suspicionless’ stop and search powers to enable police to prevent demonstrators getting to a protest

The bill doesn’t clearly define what is meant by noisy or disruptive. It is open to interpretation by those authorities on the ground at the time of the protest. As we’ve also said before – the climate debate, would not be as advanced or as accepted as it now without our activists noisily and disruptively holding government and big business to account for environmental degradation on a massive scale. The BLM movement could not have entered into mainstream consciousness without being noisy and disruptive.


You can’t really have a protest that isn’t noisy and disruptive. We believe, alongside many others in business, that restricting the rights of people to speak out does not create a healthy, diverse and prosperous society that is vital to a fairer, more equal, more sustainable economy.

What next? It's not over yet!

  • The Bill must now go back to the House of Commons for further debate, redrafts and edits
  • It is common for Bills to ping back and forth between the Lords and the Commons until both agree on the final draft
  • This doesn't mean the more draconian elements of the bill won't resurface again at some point under different wording
  • Which means we need to be vigilant to the progress of the Bill - you can monitor that here;

Other posts you may be interested in...

Edelman image

Business is now the sole institution seen as competent and ethical; government is viewed as unethical and incompetent. Business is under pressure to step into the void left by government.

Edelman Trust Barometer 2023
Consumers care about sustainability and back it up with their wallets. image

Consumers are shifting their spending toward products with ESG-related claims.

Consumers care about sustainability and back it up with their wallets. McKinsey, and NielsenIQ 2023
Tanya Joseph – creator of Sport England’s This Girl Can campaign image

Purpose will be central to rebuilding brands in the society that is emerging after the pandemic. The businesses that will not just survive, but thrive, over the coming months and years will be those whose leaders embrace the notion that there is no merit in profit without purpose.

Tanya Joseph – creator of Sport England’s This Girl Can campaign Columnist, Marketing Week

Hey there, couldn’t help noticing you’re using Internet Explorer

That’s great and all, and we commend you for pushing through with it. Unfortunately we no longer offer support for IE; it hasn’t received a major update since 2015 and Microsoft are dropping support for it later in the year.

If you’re using Windows 10 and want to stick with a built in browser, please consider switching to Edge. Or, if you really want to enjoy the internet properly we strongly recommend downloading Google Chrome here.